Patients who talked about CT lung cancer screening with their doctors were more likely to actually follow through on getting scanned. That’s according to a study this week in CHEST that offers support for shared decision making – a process that some screening proponents have criticized.
The U.S. continues to see disappointing compliance rates for CT lung cancer screening, over 10 years after the USPSTF recommended the exam.
- Some lung screening proponents suggest that one barrier to screening is a CMS rule requiring a shared decision-making session between patients and doctors before the first scan is performed – a requirement that’s not in place for any of the other major cancer screening tests.
But the new study indicates that shared decision making could actually work to boost compliance.
- Researchers from the Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute led by first author YoonKyung Chung, PhD, examined lung screening compliance rates for 22.6k people who had their first CT exam between 2016 and 2019.
Researchers looked at differences in annual follow-up lung screening rates between people who got shared decision-making sessions and those who didn’t, finding…
- Only 11% of study participants had a session before their first scan.
- One year after the initial scan, those who participated in sessions were 27% more likely to get a follow-up exam.
- Four years later, the compliance rate rose to 33%.
If CMS requires shared decision-making sessions for reimbursement, why are they occurring so infrequently?
- The authors called this phenomenon “puzzling,” and suggested it’s because CMS is not enforcing the mandate through tools like claims denial. CMS could also boost utilization by providing higher reimbursement for the discussions.
The Takeaway
The new findings suggest that shared decision making should be viewed as an opportunity rather than a barrier to convincing patients of CT lung cancer screening’s value. The results track with other studies showing that a high-touch approach with tools like patient navigators can work.