Richard Duszak, MD, commenting on a new study on medical imaging’s contribution to US healthcare costs.

Imaging Wire Sponsors

Bayer  •  Blackford  •  CARPL.ai  •  Clearpath  •  DeepHealth  •  Enlitic  •  Gleamer  •  Intelerad  •  Medality  •  Merge by Merative  •  Nuance  •  PocketHealth  •  Riverain Technologies  •  Siemens Healthineers  •  SpinTech MRI  •  TeraRecon  •  United Imaging  •  Us2.ai  •  Visage Imaging

Imaging Policy & Legislation

Imaging and US Healthcare Costs

In the debate over rising US healthcare costs, medical imaging is often painted as a bad guy. But a new study in Health Affairs Scholar claims that since 2010, spending on imaging services has not grown at the same rate as other medical services. 

It’s no secret that the US spends far more on healthcare per capita than other developed countries, spending 16.6% of GDP as of 2022 according to OECD data. 

• For point of reference, Germany spends 12.7%, France spends 12.1%, and most other developed countries spend under 12% of GDP. 

Reasons why the US is such an outlier have been blamed on a variety of factors, such as pharmaceutical prices, physician salaries, administrative costs, and the fragmented nature of the US healthcare system. 

• But medical imaging is often singled out for criticism, perhaps due to the high cost of scanners and the explosion of imaging volume since the advent of cross-sectional technologies like CT and MRI in the 1970s and 1980s. 

This has led the US government to exert major pressure on imaging reimbursement in the Medicare and Medicaid systems, starting with the Deficit Reduction Act of 2005 and continuing to the present day, while private insurers have employed tools like prior authorization. 

The new study indicates that these efforts may have accomplished their mission. Researchers from the ACR’s Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute analyzed imaging’s contribution to overall growth of medical costs from 2010 to 2021 in employer-sponsored insurance plans, finding …

• Spending on medical imaging grew 36% 
• Spending for all other healthcare services grew 64% 
• Two-thirds of the growth in imaging spending was due to general price inflation
• Only one-fifth was due to increased utilization
• Imaging’s share of total US healthcare spending fell from 10.5% to 8.9%

The findings indicate that efforts by the US government and private payors to drive down imaging utilization are working … but at the price of overworked radiology staff.

• Imaging cuts could also be leading to patient access issues, as the study found that the percentage of patients undergoing imaging fell from 46% in 2010 to 40% in 2021. 

The Takeaway

The new study reinforces what imaging advocates have been saying for years – that medical imaging isn’t a major cause for runaway healthcare spending in the US. The question is whether anyone outside of radiology is listening.

MRI Access and the Cost of Inpatient Stays

Longer inpatient stays due to delayed MRI access are a long-standing and costly issue for hospital systems. Find out how STAGE from SpinTech MRI can reduce your MRI backlog and inpatient stays by shortening brain scan times by 30%.

Salem Regional’s Case for MEDRAD Stellant FLEX

Learn how Salem Regional Medical Center improved its radiology workflows and cut service and syringe expenses after adopting Bayer’s MEDRAD Stellant FLEX system.

The Wire

• GenAI Revelations Rock Publishers: The academic publishing world has been rocked by revelations that researchers are using generative AI models like ChatGPT to write research papers. In multiple posts on Twitter/X, observers are sharing papers published in journals from mainstream publishers like Elsevier containing chatbot prompts that were not removed by authors and made it through the peer-review process. The controversy is prompting many to raise new questions about scientific publishing and the role of large publishers like Elsevier. 

• ChatGPT Simplifies Radiology Reports: On the other side of the coin, researchers simplified radiology reports for patients using four publicly available large language models – two versions of ChatGPT and Google’s Gemini and Microsoft’s Bing (presumably removing the chatbot prompts). In an article in Radiology, researchers explained how they put the LLMs to work on 750 radiology report impressions. There were variations in each model’s performance, but all worked well in simplifying reports, such as by lowering their required reading level from the 14th to the 7th grade.

• Congress Scales Back Medicare Cuts: Congress averted some of the more serious cuts in Medicare and Medicaid reimbursement with the passage last month of the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2024. An analysis by Healthcare Administrative Partners details the changes, including a reduction in the size of a cut to the RVU conversion factor, resulting in a final rate of $33.2875 per RVU, -1.77% from 2023 versus -3.37% as originally proposed. The law also boosted incentive payments for participating in Medicare’s program for alternative payment models.

• Mammo AI Works with All Breast Densities: Mammography AI combined with breast density calculations better predicts breast cancer. In European Radiology, BreastScreen Norway researchers combined ScreenPoint Medical’s Transpara AI solution with Volpara’s breast density calculations in mammograms of 75k women. In all, 11% of exams had the highest risk score (10), representing 90% of screen-detected and 45% of interval cancers; for women with extremely dense breast tissue these numbers rose to 95% and 48%, respectively. The findings show the power of combining AI with breast density analysis. 

• Siemens Lands Clearance for 7T MRI: The FDA has cleared Siemens Healthineers’ Magnetom Terra.X, the newest version of the company’s 7T MRI technology. Siemens launched the X platform in November 2022 as an update for its 3T and 7T scanners; Magnetom Cima.X was cleared in December 2023. The X upgrade includes new hardware and XA60A software, as well as the Ultra IQ eight-channel parallel transmit architecture and Deep Resolve deep-learning reconstruction algorithm for accelerated data acquisition, enabling a high-resolution brain and knee exam in under 20 minutes. 

• Brain Abnormalities Linked to Heart Disease: People with heart disease also have evidence of brain abnormalities that can be detected on imaging exams. A literature review in Neurology of 221 studies found links between various cardiac conditions and covert neurovascular abnormalities; for example, patients with atrial fibrillation have higher prevalence of silent brain infarction (36%), lacune/ischemic infarct (25%), white matter hyperintensities (62%), and microbleeds (27%). The authors speculated that reductions in cardiac output could affect cerebral perfusion, contributing to cerebral small vessel disease and cognitive dysfunction. 

• Refining Prenatal Ultrasound: Ultrasound-based prenatal measurements of nuchal translucency – fluid behind the neck of a fetus – are good predictors of chromosomal anomalies. But in JAMA Network Open, researchers suggest the existing 3.5mm nuchal translucency threshold may not be capturing as many fetal anomalies. In a study of 414k pregnancies, researchers found that fetuses with nuchal translucency measuring 3.0-3.5mm had higher risk ratios for chromosomal anomalies than those at 2.0mm or less (adjusted risk ratio=20.3); genetic testing could be recommended in these cases.

• Trial to Address Chronic Pelvic Pain: The EMBOLIZE trial has been launched to investigate interventional radiology-based treatments for women experiencing chronic pelvic pain due to pelvic venous disease. In an announcement from SIR 2024, researchers said SIR and partners the VIVA Foundation and Penumbra would study the effects of ovarian vein embolization and pelvic vein embolization by assessing pain scores that women report before and after treatment, as well as other measures like quality of life and changes in medication use. 

• Chronic Diseases Affect Lung Screening: A study in Annals of Family Medicine questions whether people with chronic diseases should receive CT lung cancer screening. Researchers interviewed 40 people from Veterans Health Administration centers with high one-year risk of hospitalization or death, finding that 26 agreed to screening after discussing it with their clinicians and 14 were screened later after originally declining. The researchers portrayed this as a failure of the shared decision-making process, but declined to state which of them would volunteer to tell Grandpa he’s too sick to be screened.

• GE Touts FDA Nod for Remote Scanning: GE HealthCare has received another FDA 510(k) clearance for remote scanning software, this time a version that supports multivendor scanning with multiple modalities. GE has exclusive distribution rights to IONIC Health’s nCommand Lite technology for MRI, CT, and PET/CT through a deal the companies signed last year; remote scanning applications enable remotely located experts to guide scans being conducted on-site by licensed radiologic technologists. Vendors believe remote scanning can help customers address technologist shortages. 

• TB Screening for Developed Countries: As tuberculosis incidence rises in developed countries, a new analysis finds that TB screening for high-risk groups could be cost-effective. In Eurosurveillance, researchers analyzed nine studies from 2008-2023 that tested screening in countries with low incidence of TB, using tools ranging from chest X-ray to tuberculin skin tests. Studies focused on higher-risk individuals, such as immigrants from higher-incidence countries; in these cases, TB screening usually met generally accepted thresholds for cost-effectiveness such as QALY and ICER. 

• SyntheticMR Gets FDA Clearance: Swedish software developer SyntheticMR has received FDA clearance for SyMRI 3D, the newest version of its quantitative brain MRI software. SyMRI 3D gives clinicians insights into brain structure and function through parcellation, or volumetric estimation of brain regions. In other news, imaging services provider SimonMed Imaging will be installing SyntheticMR’s SyMRI Neuro application at 10 additional centers to complement its existing nine sites; the software enables faster MRI workflow and provides tissue maps, volumes, and myelin measurements.

A New Solution for Cardiac MR Programs

Intelerad is making advanced cardiac solutions available whenever you want them. Learn more about the company’s new Precession application, which enables you to view, analyze, and report cardiac MR exams – all within a standard web browser.

4 Reasons Why Subscription Is Better

The KLAS-leading Intuition advanced visualization solution from TeraRecon includes all the clinical features you need, plus a growing list of exclusive subscription-only content. Learn more about what’s included.

The Resource Wire

• AI-Powered Solutions to Drive Efficiency: Explore Nuance’s latest virtual series, Home for Dinner, showcasing AI-powered solutions to drive efficiency – saving radiology teams time at work so they can be home for dinner – or whatever matters most. The next demo on April 23 will feature Nuance Precision Imaging Network for seamlessly integrating AI into your existing reporting workflow. Sign up today. 

• The Journey to Cloud-Based PACS: Radiology is looking closely at cloud-based PACS as an alternative to on-premises digital image management. Learn about providers who have made the switch with Visage Imaging in this white paper from Signify Research. 

• Enterprise Imaging on Your Terms: Meet your radiology, cardiology and all other imaging needs – on your own terms – with imaging solutions from Merge by Merative. Learn more about their award-winning solutions and request a demo today. 

• Radiology Automation Simplified: Validate, deploy, and discover radiology AI with CARPL.ai. Learn more about the company’s work in taking AI from bench to clinic by booking a demo today. 

• AMRIC’s Multimodality Approach to Medical Imaging: AMRIC is a new premium imaging clinic on Manhattan’s Upper East Side. Learn about their multimodality approach to medical imaging and why they turned to United Imaging for cutting-edge CT, MRI, and molecular imaging technology. 

• The Smooth Deployment of Lung AI: Seamless use of AI wouldn’t be possible without workflow integration, made possible in collaboration with hospital IT teams. Learn about the smooth deployment of DeepHealth’s Saige Lung solution at Portsmouth Hospitals University NHS Trust in the UK.

• Missed Appointments and No-Show Costs Can Add Up: Every missed appointment can cost providers an average of $200. Find out how providers are reducing no-show rates by up to 30% with Appointment Reminders by PocketHealth.

• Making Advanced Cardiac CT Accessible Everywhere: How do you bring cardiac CT to high-risk patients in rural areas? Watch this video from Siemens Healthineers to learn insights into setting up a cardiovascular CT program in a rural area – and how to overcome associated challenges.

• Monetizing Medical Imaging with a Real-World Database: Data-driven decision-making is more important than ever. In this article from Enlitic, learn how you can leverage your medical imaging data by creating a real-world database. 

• Data Sourcing for Medical AI: Join Gleamer and its partner Gradient Health for a webinar on data sourcing for medical AI at 10 am ET on April 3. Learn from Remi Quilliet of Gleamer and Rod Greco of Gradient how they worked together to speed up AI development.

• Automated Solutions for Patient and Provider Sharing: What’s the latest news from Clearpath? Find out how its fully automated patient and provider solutions for sharing medical records and images are making waves in healthcare.

• The Artistry of Radiology: How can an appreciation for fine art influence a radiologist’s image interpretation? Find out in this edition of The Radiology Report podcast, featuring Erin Cooke, MD, and Medality Co-Founder and CEO Daniel Arnold. 

• Leveraging a Proven Echo AI Platform: Us2.ai has developed a promising new pathway for bringing custom echo AI applications into widespread clinical and commercial use – historically a challenge for algorithms produced by health systems and academic institutions. Find out how it worked in Uganda in this article.

• Focus on Actionable Data: Riverain Technologies’ ClearRead technology is the first FDA-cleared Clear Visual Intelligence (CVI) system that improves both detection and reading time for lung abnormalities. Learn more in this article. 

• Major Milestones in Platform AI: It was a busy year for AI platform developer Blackford. We reviewed the company’s major milestones in this video interview from RSNA 2023, in which we talked to Blackford executives David Hilderbrand and Anthony Cammack.