|
Are Doctors Overpaid? | Vendor Earnings Momentum
August 10, 2023
|
|
|
|
|
Together with
|
|
|
|
“What makes me angry is the CEO incomes for hospitals, insurance companies & most everything involved in the actual causes of the high cost of healthcare in this country that makes healthcare unaffordable for many.”
|
|
Frumious, in an AuntMinnie forum thread on physician salaries.
|
|
|
|
A new study on physician salaries is raising pointed questions about pay for US physicians and whether it contributes to rising healthcare costs – that is, if you believe the numbers are accurate.
The study was released in July by the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), which produces in-depth reports on a variety of topics.
The current paper is highly technical and may have languished in obscurity were it not for an August 4 article in The Washington Post that examined the findings with the claim that “doctors make more than anyone thought.”
It is indeed true that the NBER’s estimate of physician salaries seems high. The study claims US physicians made an average of $350k in 2017, the year that the researchers focused on by analyzing federal tax records.
- The NBER estimate is far higher than $294k in Medscape’s 2017 report on physician compensation – a 19% difference.
The variation is even greater for diagnostic radiologists. The NBER data claim radiologists had a median annual salary in 2017 of $546k – 38% higher than the $396k average salary listed in Medscape’s 2017 report.
- The NBER numbers from six years ago are even higher than 2022/2023 numbers for radiologist salaries in several recent reports, by Medscape ($483k), Doximity ($504k), and Radiology Business ($482k).
But the NBER researchers claim that by analyzing tax data rather than relying on self-reported earnings, their data are more accurate than previous studies, which they believe underestimate physician salaries by as much as 25%.
- They also estimate that physician salaries make up about 9% of total US healthcare costs.
What difference is it how much physicians make? The WaPo story sparked a debate with 6.1k comments so far, with many readers accusing doctors of contributing to runaway healthcare costs in the US.
- Meanwhile, a thread in the AuntMinnie forums argued whether the NBER numbers were accurate, with some posters warning that the figures could lead to additional cuts in Medicare payments for radiologists.
The Takeaway
Lost in the debate over the NBER report is its finding that physician pay makes up only 9% of US healthcare costs. In a medical system that’s rife with overutilization, administrative costs, and duplicated effort across fragmented healthcare networks, physician salaries should be the last target for those who actually want to cut healthcare spending.
|
|
|
What Can We Do About Physician Burnout?
Clinical burnout is widespread in healthcare. What can be done to combat burnout in imaging? Listen to Sonia Gupta, MD, chief medical officer of enterprise imaging at Change Healthcare, as she addresses concerns and offers possible solutions that you can use right now.
|
|
Fast. Flexible. Modern.
United Imaging’s service organization is called Customer Success for a reason. Their mission is to think ahead, understand their customers’ goals, and proactively help customers achieve them. They also store critical service parts in the U.S. and back up their promises with the United Performance Guarantee.
|
|
- Vendor Earnings Momentum: With the summer earnings season drawing to a close, radiology vendors appear to have continued the momentum they showed with spring financial results. At constant currency rates, most companies saw year-over-year revenue growth, including GE HealthCare Imaging and Ultrasound divisions (+11% to $3.5B), Siemens Healthineers Imaging division (+15% to $3.1B), Philips Diagnosis & Treatment division (+12% to $2.3B), Fujifilm Medical Systems (+7.5% to $981M), Canon Medical Systems (+7% to $883M), Hologic Breast Health division (+27.5% to $360M), and Varex Imaging (+8% to $232M). Going the other direction was Butterfly Network, which saw a revenue decline (-3.8% to $19M).
- Study Disproves Room-Temp Supercon Claims: The arrival of room-temperature superconducting may have to wait for another day. A new study posted to the ArXiv server by Chinese scientists says that the “half levitation” effect observed in a sample of LK-99 material was due to “weak yet definitive soft ferromagnetic components” that were enough to explain the phenomenon. South Korean researchers last month proposed that LK-99 possessed superconducting properties at room temperature, which if proven could have a big impact on fields like MRI.
- NVIDIA Releases Generative AI Toolkit: Graphics processing unit giant NVIDIA has released AI Workbench, a toolkit designed to help developers create generative AI models on a PC or workstation. The toolkit is designed to remove the complexity of getting started with an enterprise AI project, and generative AI algorithms developed with AI Workbench can be scaled to virtually any data center, public cloud, or NVIDIA’s own DGX Cloud. Along with AI Workbench, NVIDIA released AI Enterprise 4.0, the latest version of its enterprise software platform.
- MRI Radiomics for Cardiac Amyloidosis: A radiomics score derived from cardiac MRI excelled in predicting all-cause mortality in cardiac amyloidosis patients. In European Radiology, researchers described their development of Rad-score, which combines radiomics features from late gadolinium enhancement (LGE) MRI scans. In 120 cardiac amyloidosis patients, Rad-score better predicted mortality than LGE total enhancement mass and LGE extent (AUC=0.77 vs. 0.54 and 0.53, respectively), and Rad-score combined with Mayo stage was better than Mayo stage alone (0.86 vs. 0.81).
- Fresenius Launches Generic Gadavist: Fresenius Kabi is launching gadobutrol, the company’s generic version of the gadolinium-based contrast agent marketed by Bayer as Gadavist. The GBCA is the fourth contrast offering in Fresenius Kabi’s radiology portfolio, which also includes the MRI agent gadoterate meglumine (generic of Guerbet’s Dotarem), X-ray agent iodixanol (generic of GE HealthCare’s Visipaque), and gallbladder contraction stimulating agent sincalide (generic of Bracco Diagnostics’ Kinevac).
- Overdiagnosis in Older Women: A new study in Annals of Internal Medicine claimed to have found a high rate of overdiagnosis in women over 70 who got breast screening. Researchers said up to 31% of the cancers detected in a group of nearly 55k women never would have caused symptoms during the patient’s lifetime, and overdiagnosis rates went up as women got older. The researchers declined to weigh in on whether the harms of overdiagnosis outweigh the benefits of screening older women, however.
- Study Supports Screening Younger Women: At the other end of the breast screening spectrum, a new study supports the idea that 40 is the best age to start. Researchers in Journal of Clinical Oncology found that Canadian provinces that screened women in their 40s had net breast cancer survival rates 2.6 percentage points higher than those that started at 50. Screening’s advantage was particularly pronounced for women 45-49. The study reinforces the USPSTF decision to change its recommended starting age for regular breast screening to 40.
- Penn. Provider Adopts Volpara: Penn Highlands Healthcare in Pennsylvania has implemented Volpara’s Patient Hub patient management software. The solution replaces manual paper tracking with customizable mammography reporting and patient communication options, and is designed to ensure patients receive regular breast screening and follow-up care. Penn Highlands also recently began using Volpara’s Scorecard software to measure breast density.
- Annalise Scores Enterprise CTB Clearances: Annalise.ai’s Enterprise CTB software for AI analysis of non-contrast head CT scans has received new regulatory clearances. The software has received a class IIb CE Mark under the European Union’s Medical Device Regulation, and has also been approved for clinical use in Singapore. The company noted that the certifications also extend to its Enterprise CXR software for chest X-rays.
- Rad Therapy Volume Linked to Survival: Radiation therapy facilities that performed a higher volume of procedures had higher rates of overall patient survival. In a new study in JAMA Network Open, researchers analyzed survival in 25k men with very high-risk prostate cancer treated from 2004 to 2016, finding that survival was greater at high-volume facilities compared to low-volume sites (123 vs. 109 months). Patients treated at high-volume sites also had a lower risk of death (HR=0.89).
- Subtle Lands on List of Gen AI Firms: Subtle Medical was named one of the 50 most promising private generative AI companies by market research firm CB Insights. Subtle was one of four healthcare companies and the only one in medical imaging on the GenAI 50 list, with firms picked based on criteria that included R&D activity, business relationships, team strength, and other factors. Subtle in June was named to CB Insights’ list of top 100 AI firms worldwide.
- CARPL Aids Singapore AI project: CARPL.ai’s platform has been adopted as part of a large project to promote the use of AI in the Singapore healthcare system. The country’s Synapxe health technology agency is implementing a vendor-neutral AI platform called AimSG to support the roll-out of AI models across the country, and CARPL serves as the platform for the project. The company has already successfully deployed Lunit’s Insight CXR algorithm at two major hospitals.
- Qure Supports Nigeria TB Screening: Qure.ai is supporting a tuberculosis screening program in Nigeria that pairs the company’s qXR AI algorithm with MinXray’s portable X-ray system. Operated by Caritas Nigeria, the program has doctors reviewing results on-site; patients suspected of having TB are referred for additional testing and if positive are given treatment to prevent the spread of further infection.
|
|
How Thomas Jefferson Leveraged CARPL.ai
See how Thomas Jefferson University relied on CARPL.ai to accelerate its AI validation and clinical adoption in this presentation by informatics and AI leader, Dr. Paras Lakhani.
|
|
Delighting Patients with Medical Image Sharing
A new platform from Clearpath now enables healthcare providers to delight their patients by sharing images and medical records digitally. Find out how it integrates simply into your practice.
|
|
- Multinuclear spectroscopy and imaging (MNSI) is a developing technique for assessing biological and metabolic changes in diseases. Learn more about how advances in MR hardware and software are moving the MNSI field forward in this article from GE HealthCare.
- When one of Precision Imaging Centers’ 3T MRIs wasn’t meeting their requirements, they implemented Subtle Medical’s SubtleMR solution, rather than purchasing a new scanner or an expensive upgrade. See how SubtleMR enhanced Precision’s patient throughput and comfort without compromising image quality in this case study.
- Learn how Einstein Healthcare Network reduced its syringe expenses, enhanced its syringe loading, and improved its contrast documentation when it upgraded to Bayer Radiology’s MEDRAD Stellant FLEX CT Injection System.
- With burnout and staffing shortages on the rise, and the increasing volume of imaging, radiology teams are searching for solutions. This interactive guide from Nuance can help you create an environment where radiologists thrive by building a powerful imaging strategy with AI-driven, real-time intelligence.
- Health boards in Scotland are working with AI on a trial basis for tasks such as cancer screening. Find out how NHS Grampian’s radiology department turned to Annalise.ai to identify abnormalities on chest radiographs.
- More than 80% of health systems are reporting shortages in their radiology departments. Learn the countermeasures you can take to reduce burnout in this ITN Online article by Intelerad President Morris Panner.
- Check out this Blackford Analysis video detailing how its platform streamlines AI adoption and workflows, allowing radiology teams to achieve AI’s clinical benefits without operational sacrifices.
- EHRs are more than just digital filing cabinets – they are trusted tools that can help providers engage and retain patients. Learn more about the benefits of EHRs in this article from PocketHealth.
- Healthcare providers can’t feel confident in the impact they make for their patients without feeling their IT environments are resilient and reliable. This eBook from Merge breaks down 3 essential ingredients of a resilient imaging IT environment: hybrid cloud, reliable uptime, and zero-trust security.
- Medical data has emerged as a critical resource for driving better patient outcomes. But how can we improve data collection? This article from Enlitic describes how its Curie|ENDEX technology can help.
- In a new research study in Clinical Imaging, see how Visage Imaging’s PACS-integrated Visage Breast Density application had high accuracy and agreement with radiologist assessments for classifying mammography exams into BI-RADS categories.
- Learn about how Us2.ai is bringing simplicity and clarity to the world of echo AI and cardiac ultrasound on the latest episode of The Bleeding Edge of Digital Health featuring Us2.ai’s founders, James Hare and Dr. Carolyn Lam.
- What’s happening at the intersection of AI and precision medicine? In this Imaging Wire Show, we talked to Chiranjiv Singh, general manager at Arterys, a Tempus Labs company, about their vision for building a 360° view of the patient.
|
|
|
|
|
